Small business and the Goods and Services Tax: Compliance cost issues and estimates
The introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in Australia on 1 July 2000 forms a key part of the Government's major tax reform policies. Small businesses, around 900,000 firms, play a central role in the GST and Pay-As-You-Go systems, acting as 'unpaid tax collectors', and allegedly face an onerous and unfair burden.
This paper reviews international compliance cost evidence on small business GST compliance costs, particularly recurrent costs. The major issues currently facing small business and likely to emerge in GST policy debate are discussed. The tentative evidence to date on small business GST start-up costs is reviewed, and the difficulty of assigning economic joint costs, particularly for computer equipment, is recognised.
Studies to date suggest small business average GST start-up costs of around $3,000 to $6,000, but with a wide variation experienced. Gross GST start-up compliance costs for small business would be of the order of at least $4 billion, higher than original Government indications. The importance of managerial benefits and savings arising from technology eg on-line lodgement and transfers, is discussed. The paper concludes by identifying possible emerging issues.
Tax Policy Research Unit, School of Economics and Finance, Curtin University, Perth WA
Curtin University of Technology, Perth WA
AC Nielsen (1999) CPA Small Business Survey, for the Australian Society of Certified Practising Accountants [ASCPA], August.
Australian Financial Review [AFR] (2000a) Small talk now from politicians, July 4, p6.
Australian Financial Review [AFR] (2000b) Pollsters counsel caution on how the polls see fallout, June 22, p4.
Australian Financial Review [AFR] (2000c) ABN register log jammed, 1 June, p3.
Australian Financial Review [AFR] (2000d) Tax Office throws ABN lifeline, June 27, p4.
Australian Financial Review [AFR], (2000e) Readiness for GST tipped to cost $24bn, 6 January, p6.
Australian Financial Review [AFR], (2001), Business wins on BAS, and Cash flow still a concern for small business, 23 February, p1 and 10 respectively.
Australian Society of Certified Public Accountants [ASCPA] (1999) A research report on A Survey of Micro-Business, Study No. 99/09/2535.
Australian Taxation Office (2000), Response to Regulation Impact Statements (RISs) and Compliance Costs, ATAX Compliance Cost Conference, 27 April.
Bell Report (1996) Time for Business, Report of the Small Business Deregulation Task Force, Department of Industry, Science and Technology, (037/96), Canberra.
Brooks, N. (1992) The Canadian Goods and Services Tax: History, Policy and Politics, Sydney: Australian Tax Research Foundation.
Canadian Federation of Independent Business (1991) The GST: A National Tax Tragedy, Toronto.
Cnossen, S. (1994) Administrative and Compliance Costs of the VAT: A Review of the Evidence, International Tax and Public Finance, 5, pp399-428.
Cordova-Novion, C. and De Young, C. (2000) The OECD Management Service Multi-Country Business Survey: Benchmarking Regulatory and Administrative Business Environments in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises, Paper presented at the ATAX Compliance Costs Symposium, 26-27 April, Sydney, and in Evans, C, Pope, J. and Hasseldine, J. (Ed., 2001), Taxation Compliance Costs: A Festschrift for Cedric Sandford, Prospect Media Pty Ltd, St. Leonards, NSW.
Dubroof, S. (1991) Computerisation for VAT, in Tait, A. (Ed) Value-Added Tax: Administrative and Policy Issues pp58-66, International Monetary Fund, Washington DC.
Economic Development Committee, Parliament of Victoria Report (2000) Inquiry into the Impact of the Goods and Services Tax on Small and Medium Sized Business in Victoria, GST Report No. 1, November.
Ernst & Young (1999) The Impact of the Goods and Services Tax on Small Business in New South Wales - A report to the New South Wales Department of State and Regional Development.
Evans, C, and Ryan, A. (1999) Tax Reform Issues for Small Business, at http://www.cpaonline.com.au, pp1-62.
Evans, C, Ritchie K., Tran-Nam, Binh and Walpole, M. (1997), Taxpayer Costs of Compliance, Australian Taxation Office, AGPS, Canberra [Often referred to as the 1997 ATAX study].
Joint Government's Advocate (2000) GST Implementation and Compliance Costs, Attachment ID in letter to the President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission Bench, 31 March.
National Audit Office of the UK (1994) HM Customs and Excise: Cost to Business of Complying with VAT Requirements, London: HMSO.
Plamondon and Associates Inc. (1993) GST Compliance Costs for Small Business in Canada, Department of Finance, Government of Canada [Summarised in Wurts, B., in Sandford, C. (Ed. 1995), pp299-320].
Poutziouris, P. Chittenden, F. and Michaelas, N. (1999) Modeling the Impact of Taxation on the Small Business Economy: The NatWest MBS Tax Index for the Self Employed, Sole Traders and Partnerships, Manchester Business School.
Pope, J. (1998) The Compliance Cost Implications of the Government's Tax Reform Proposals, Business Coalition for Tax Reform Discussion Paper, December. [Cited in Business Coalition for Tax Reform, Submission to the Senate Select Committee on A New Tax System (February 1999), pp4 and 29 (extracts)]
Pope, J. (1999) The Compliance Costs of the Goods and Services Tax: Major Issues, Economic Papers, 18 (2), pp61-77.
Pope, J. (2000a) The Administrative and Compliance Costs of International Taxation, mimeo and in Lymer, A. and Hasseldine, J. (Ed., 2002 forthcoming), International Taxation, Kluwer, UK.
Pope, J. (2000b) Tax Compliance Costs: The Value of Cash Flow Benefits to Business and the Effect of the Pay-As-You-Go System, Paper presented at the Fourth International Conference on Tax Administration, 28-29 April 2000, Sydney, and in Walpole, M. and Evans, C. (Ed., 2001), Tax Administration in the Third Millennium, Prospect Media Pty Ltd, Sydney.
Pope, J. (2000c) Factors affecting the Compliance Costs of the Goods and Services Tax in Australia, Paper presented at the ATAX Compliance Costs Symposium, 26-27 April, Sydney, and in Evans, C, Pope, J. and Hasseldine, J. (Ed., 2001), Taxation Compliance Costs: A Festschrift for Cedric Sandford, Prospect Media Pty Ltd, St. Leonards, NSW.
Pope, J. Fernandez, P. and Hawke, A. (1999) GST and Small Business: A Preliminary Study (mimeo).
'Ralph' Report (1999) Review of Business Taxation, Chaired by Mr John Ralph, A Tax System Re- Designed, Final Report, July, and A Platform for Consultation, Discussion Paper 2: Building on a Strong Foundation, February, at www.rbt.treasury.gov.au. Regulation Impact Statement for the Introduction of a Goods and Services Tax (RIS, 1998) accompanying A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Bill 1998, presented to Parliament, December, Canberra.
RSM Bird Cameron (2000) Survey on Compliance Costs, commissioned by and cited in the Economic Development Committee, Parliament of Victoria Report (2000, pp40-45).
Sandford, C.T., Godwin, M.R. and Hardwick, P.J.W. (1989) Administrative and Compliance Costs of Taxation, Fiscal Publications, Bath.
Sandford, C, Godwin, M. and Hardwick, P and Butterworth, M. (1981) Costs and Benefits of VAT, Heinemann, London.
Sandford, C.T. and Hasseldine, J. (1992) The Compliance Costs of Business Taxes in New Zealand, Institute of Policy Studies, Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington.
Sandford, C. (Ed) 1995 Tax Compliance Costs Measurement and Policy, Fiscal Publications, Bath.
Tourism Council of Australia (TCA, 2000) GST Implementation Survey, National Policy and Research Unit, Sydney.
Tran-Nam, B., Evans, C, Ritchie, K. and Walpole, M. (2000) Tax Compliance Costs: Research Methodology and Empirical Evidence from Australia, National Tax Journal, 53 (2), pp229-252.
Victorian Employers' Chamber of Commerce and Industry [VECCI] (1999) Special Questions - GST Compliance Burden, Survey of Business Trends and Prospects, September Quarter Performance and December Quarter 1999 Outlook, No. 20, Melbourne.
Victorian Employers' Chamber of Commerce and Industry [VECCI] (2000), Impact of the GST on Victorian Business, September, Melbourne. [Refer Economic Development Committee, Parliament of Victoria Report (2000), pp186-196].
PP: 042 - 054